- Sally Rychlak

- Aug 23
- 2 min read
by Sally Rychlak

I had a package of gluten-free graham crackers in my pantry that was rapidly approaching the end of its honorable life, which is really the entire reason these cheesecakes exist.

I didn't want to throw them away, but I also wasn't particularly interested in just eating a sleeve of graham crackers. Cheesecake felt like the better option.

I crushed the graham crackers with a rolling pin, mixed them with a little melted butter and pressed everything into parchment-lined muffin tins. From there, I wanted to see if I could make a higher-protein cheesecake filling without turning it into one of those desserts that tastes aggressively healthy.
The filling is incredibly simple: cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, an egg and vanilla protein powder. I blended everything with my immersion blender until completely smooth.

My first taste of the filling, though, was very... dairy. That's the only way I know how to describe it. It was just a lot happening at once until I brought in the lemon. The zest of an entire lemon completely changed it. It brightened everything up and made it taste much more like an actual cheesecake filling. I wouldn't skip it.

At the last minute, I pulled some wild blueberries out of the freezer, scattered them over the tops and swirled them into the filling. And thus, the pantry clean-out cheesecake became blueberry lemon cheesecake.
These are baked individually in a muffin tin, which makes them easy to portion and honestly a lot less intimidating than making an entire cheesecake. Let them chill completely before eating them. Straight out of the oven they're good, but cold from the refrigerator is when the texture becomes reminiscent of cheesecake.

They're gluten free if you use gluten-free graham crackers, higher in protein thanks to the cottage cheese, Greek yogurt and protein powder, and just sweet enough to still feel like dessert.
All because I refused to let a package of graham crackers go to waste.













